Insights · Diminished Value
Vehicle Diminished Value in Türkiye: Conditions, Calculation and Procedure
A repaired vehicle does not regain its pre-accident value. Who can claim the difference, from whom, how and by when?
Even when an accident-damaged vehicle is repaired flawlessly, its recorded damage history means it will sell for less on the second-hand market. The difference between the vehicle's market value before the accident and its value after repair is known as diminished value and is a head of actual loss under Turkish law.
Who can claim, and from whom?
The claim belongs to the owner of a vehicle who was not wholly at fault; in cases of shared fault, compensation is recoverable in proportion to the other party's fault. It may be directed against the at-fault driver, the vehicle's operator and the other vehicle's compulsory motor liability insurer. The insurer's liability is capped at the per-vehicle property damage limit of the policy; any excess is recoverable from the driver and the operator.
Calculation
The assessment takes account of the make, model, age and mileage of the vehicle, its pre-accident market value, the nature of the damage and the parts repaired, and any earlier damage history. Following the Constitutional Court's annulment decision of 2020 and the subsequent legislative amendment, the method of calculation remains contested in practice; the courts focus on the actual loss — the difference between the two market values — as determined by expert evidence.
Procedure
Under Article 97 of the Highway Traffic Act, a written claim must be submitted to the insurer before litigation or arbitration. If the insurer does not reply within fifteen days, or its reply does not satisfy the claim, the claimant may apply to the Insurance Arbitration Commission or bring court proceedings.
Limitation
Claims become time-barred two years after the claimant learns of the loss and the liable party, and in any event ten years after the accident (Article 109). Where the accident also constitutes a criminal offence, the longer criminal limitation period applies.
Related Case Law
- Constitutional Court · Constitutionality ReviewE. 2019/40 · K. 2020/40 · 17 Jul 2020 · Official Gazette 9 Oct 2020, No. 31269Compensation cannot be left to general conditions
The Court annulled the wording in Article 90 of the Highway Traffic Act that tied compensation to the insurance general conditions, together with Article 92(i). It held that leaving the scope of the insurer's obligation to the administration, without a statutory framework, was unconstitutional.
- Court of Cassation · 4th Civil ChamberE. 2021/21252 · K. 2022/5913 · 25 Mar 2022Diminished value is the gap in resale value
In a reversal in the interest of the law, the Chamber stated that diminished value is the difference between the vehicle's undamaged second-hand value before the accident and its second-hand value after repair; that relying on the general-conditions formula instead was wrong; and that the annulment decision must be applied in pending cases.
- Court of Cassation · 17th Civil ChamberE. 2019/2991 · K. 2020/6304 · 27 Oct 2020A report that ignores the test cannot ground a judgment
Diminished value is determined by the difference between the vehicle's undamaged second-hand market value before the accident and its second-hand market value as repaired; a judgment cannot rest on an expert report that departs from this test. The costs of the evidence-preservation proceedings count as litigation costs.