Insights · Health Law
How a Medical Malpractice Claim Proceeds in Türkiye
Conditions of liability, the patient file, expert evidence, heads of damage, insurance and the criminal dimension.
A medical malpractice claim does not turn on the adverse outcome itself, but on whether that outcome was caused by conduct falling below the medical standard. As a rule the physician owes a diligent intervention rather than a cure — but is liable even for slight negligence.
Conditions of liability
Four elements must be established together: an act or omission contrary to current medical standards, fault, damage, and a causal link between the two. Private hospitals also answer for the acts of the physicians and auxiliary staff they engage.
The patient file
Medical records are the backbone of the case. Patients are entitled to request a copy of their records. Incomplete or careless record-keeping may be weighed against the healthcare provider in the proceedings.
Expert evidence
Fault is assessed by the relevant specialist board of the Council of Forensic Medicine (Adli Tıp Kurumu) or by panels drawn from the relevant university departments. The report must be reasoned and open to review; inadequate or contradictory reports can be challenged and a report from a new panel requested.
Heads of damage
Claimants may seek treatment costs, loss of earnings, loss arising from reduced earning capacity and non-pecuniary damages. In fatal cases, relatives may claim loss of support and non-pecuniary damages.
Professional liability insurance
Medical malpractice liability insurance is compulsory for physicians. The claim may also be directed against the insurer within the policy limit, which matters for actual recovery.
The criminal dimension
A malpractice allegation may also be investigated as negligent injury or negligent homicide. Under a legislative amendment of 2022, the investigation of physicians requires the permission of the Professional Liability Board within the Ministry of Health.
Time limits
Limitation depends on the legal nature of the relationship: contractual and tort periods apply to private providers, while application deadlines to the administration apply to public hospitals. When time starts to run is disputed in many cases, so an assessment should not be delayed.
Related Case Law
- Court of Cassation · General Assembly of Civil ChambersE. 2018/(13)3-849 · K. 2021/1385 · 11 Nov 2021Disclosure must be examined for injections too
Sciatic nerve damage followed a post-operative injection. The General Assembly held that the injection formed part of the surgical intervention, that the court must also consider whether the patient had been informed of the possible risks, and that a reviewable report from a panel of university experts was required; it quashed the lower court's decision to persist.
- Constitutional Court · Individual ApplicationApp. No. 2021/22380 · 14 May 2025A consent objection cannot be left unexamined
The applicant suffered nerve damage during a biopsy; the lower courts did not examine her objection that she had not been informed of the risks. Noting that the burden of proving consent lies with the hospital and the physician, the Court found a violation of the right to protect one's physical and mental integrity and ordered a retrial.
- Constitutional Court · Individual ApplicationApp. No. 2021/13476 · 15 Jan 2025 · Official Gazette 2 Oct 2025, No. 33035A token award is not adequate redress
The applicant suffered organ perforation during a procedure, and a criminal court had established that the signature on the consent form was not hers. An award of TRY 4,000 in non-pecuniary damages was held disproportionate to the harm; the Court found a violation and ordered a retrial.