Insights · Health Law

Informed Consent in Türkiye: Who Bears the Burden of Proof?

Even a properly performed intervention is unlawful without valid consent. Scope of disclosure, proof and the competent court.

A medical intervention is unlawful under Turkish law if it is not based on the patient's valid consent — even where it was performed in accordance with medical standards. Consent is valid only if the patient knew what they were consenting to, which presupposes adequate disclosure.

Scope of disclosure

Under the Patient Rights Regulation, the patient must be told the diagnosis, who will perform the proposed intervention and where and how, the expected benefits, the possible risks and complications, the alternatives, and the consequences of refusing treatment. The information must be given in language the patient can understand and a reasonable time in advance. For international patients, the use of an interpreter and a form in the patient's own language is decisive.

Burden of proof

According to the settled practice of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay), the physician and the healthcare provider bear the burden of proving that disclosure took place. Pre-printed, generic forms that do not address the risks of the specific procedure, or documents signed hurriedly just before surgery, may not be accepted as sufficient on their own.

Complication versus malpractice

A complication is an outcome that is foreseeable but unavoidable even with due care, and as a rule does not give rise to liability. Liability may arise, however, where the risk was not disclosed beforehand or the complication was not properly managed once it occurred.

Competent courts

Claims against private hospitals and practices are in practice heard by the consumer courts, and mediation must be attempted before filing. Where treatment was provided in a public or state university hospital, the claim is brought against the administration as a full-remedy action before the administrative courts; a prior application to the administration is required within one year of learning of the damage and in any event within five years.

Related Case Law

  • Constitutional Court · Individual ApplicationApp. No. 2021/22380 · 14 May 2025A consent objection cannot be left unexamined

    The applicant suffered nerve damage during a biopsy; the lower courts did not examine her objection that she had not been informed of the risks. Noting that the burden of proving consent lies with the hospital and the physician, the Court found a violation of the right to protect one's physical and mental integrity and ordered a retrial.

  • Constitutional Court · Individual ApplicationApp. No. 2021/13476 · 15 Jan 2025 · Official Gazette 2 Oct 2025, No. 33035A token award is not adequate redress

    The applicant suffered organ perforation during a procedure, and a criminal court had established that the signature on the consent form was not hers. An award of TRY 4,000 in non-pecuniary damages was held disproportionate to the harm; the Court found a violation and ordered a retrial.

  • Court of Cassation · General Assembly of Civil ChambersE. 2018/(13)3-849 · K. 2021/1385 · 11 Nov 2021Disclosure must be examined for injections too

    Sciatic nerve damage followed a post-operative injection. The General Assembly held that the injection formed part of the surgical intervention, that the court must also consider whether the patient had been informed of the possible risks, and that a reviewable report from a panel of university experts was required; it quashed the lower court's decision to persist.

  • Court of Cassation · 3rd Civil ChamberE. 2025/531 · K. 2026/1285 · 9 Mar 2026Disclosure and consent are for the physician to prove

    The lower court had decided the case on the ground that the duty to keep the consent form lay with a hospital not party to the proceedings, without allowing the physicians to prove that they had informed the patient and obtained informed consent. The Chamber found this contrary to procedure and law and quashed the judgment.