Insights · Diminished Value

When the Insurer Rejects or Underpays a Diminished Value Claim

Grounds for refusal, the release-form risk, arbitration versus court, and the documents you need.

A significant share of diminished value claims are rejected by insurers or settled below the actual loss. That response is not final; legal remedies remain open.

Common grounds for refusal

Insurers typically rely on exclusions in the general conditions, the vehicle's earlier damage record, the allocation of fault or missing documents. The courts' yardstick is actual loss: a restriction in the general conditions does not in every case bar recovery of the diminished value established by expert evidence.

Take care with release forms

A release signed on receipt of a partial payment can make it harder to claim the balance. Under Article 111 of the Highway Traffic Act, however, settlements on the amount of compensation that are manifestly inadequate or excessive may be annulled within two years of the date they were made.

The Insurance Arbitration Commission

If the written claim to the insurer is unsuccessful, the matter can be referred to the Commission. The review is conducted on the documents and the arbitrator's award is, as a rule, issued within four months. Awards above certain amounts can be challenged and appealed; the monetary thresholds are updated annually.

Arbitration or court?

Arbitration is faster but is available only against the insurer and only up to the policy limit. Losses exceeding the limit, and uninsured heads such as loss of use, must be claimed in court from the at-fault driver and the operator. The choice of route depends on the size of the loss and the other side's ability to pay.

Documents required

The accident report, the appraisal report, repair invoices and parts list, the registration certificate, photographs of the damage and, where possible, an independent diminished value report.

Interest

The insurer must pay within eight working days of receiving the required documents (Article 99). Once that period expires the insurer is in default and interest begins to accrue — which is why a complete, documented claim matters.

Related Case Law

  • Court of Cassation · 4th Civil ChamberE. 2021/21252 · K. 2022/5913 · 25 Mar 2022Diminished value is the gap in resale value

    In a reversal in the interest of the law, the Chamber stated that diminished value is the difference between the vehicle's undamaged second-hand value before the accident and its second-hand value after repair; that relying on the general-conditions formula instead was wrong; and that the annulment decision must be applied in pending cases.

  • Court of Cassation · 17th Civil ChamberE. 2019/2991 · K. 2020/6304 · 27 Oct 2020A report that ignores the test cannot ground a judgment

    Diminished value is determined by the difference between the vehicle's undamaged second-hand market value before the accident and its second-hand market value as repaired; a judgment cannot rest on an expert report that departs from this test. The costs of the evidence-preservation proceedings count as litigation costs.

  • Constitutional Court · Constitutionality ReviewE. 2019/40 · K. 2020/40 · 17 Jul 2020 · Official Gazette 9 Oct 2020, No. 31269Compensation cannot be left to general conditions

    The Court annulled the wording in Article 90 of the Highway Traffic Act that tied compensation to the insurance general conditions, together with Article 92(i). It held that leaving the scope of the insurer's obligation to the administration, without a statutory framework, was unconstitutional.